Wednesday, 4 December 2024

On 4K HD - David Hare swoons over PARIS TEXAS (Wim Wenders, 1984) and adds a thought about THE THIRD MAN (Carol Reed, 1949)


Direct from Paree aujourd’hui.

Wenders Paris Texas in a new 4K 2024 restoration. I have the earlier 2022 Criterion and honestly wondered how much better this could get.

 

It is amazing. The clarity’s more film-like than ever. Depth and grain are like velvet. You get the feeling from watching this 4K that Robby Mũller was really falling in love with the super clean light of the Texas locations. The 2014 version which was the basis for previous discs managed all of that, but the new 4K with HDR/DV seems to capture the real “bloom” of Eastman Kodak stock (perhaps the “Vision” line.) There is a feeling of textural refinement that seems to cocoon each image, regardless of the striking slices of colour that constantly play with the eyes. 

 

If you are thinking about making a move to 4K this might be a decider, along with next month’s 4K remaster of The Searchers.

 

I bought the Carlotta release because they usually get all their encodes from David McKenzie. This release is only enabled for English French and German territories and comes with the expected language and audio options, including a totally gorgeous 5.1 mix which knocks the Ry Cooder score outta the room. 

 

Madman is releasing a version of this next month in Australia, but for reasons I cannot comprehend only in DVD and Blu-ray formats. But that’s their nightmare I guess. 

 


Oh, the Canal disc of the Carol Reed
The Third Man picture thats another McKenzie encoding and is, if it could be possible, even more refined and texturally cinematic than the Canal/Criterion Blu-ray of two years ago. 

 

Worthy distractions from the circus that is now becoming the slow death of the American Empire.

Monday, 2 December 2024

Sixty Years of Art Cinema 1960-2020 : Bruce Hodsdon continues his series - Phases in East Central Europe 1949-80 beginning with 6 (36) Poland

  

Poster for A Generation (Andrzej Wajda, 1954)

The postwar decades in Poland, Hungary, the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Yugoslavia and Bulgaria, can be divided into three distinct periods*.       

1949-56 The imposition of a totalitarian Stalinism involving the suppression of the avant-garde periods in art history and film and the aggressive endorsement of the ‘official art’: a template of social realism imposed through total state control of production and exhibition.

1956-68  The Stalinist “Thaw” marked by some regional liberalisation (Poland 1956-60, the Prague Spring 1963-8, Yugoslavia 1956-61, Hungary after 1963) in respect of theme and style in films, alternating with Russian military suppression ( Hungary 1956 and of the Prague Spring in 1968). A borderline phenomena between ‘official’ and ‘unofficial’ art : the aesthetic rehabilitation of the historical avant garde; some penetration of Western influences. The emergence of a new generation of filmmakers born in the 1930s: the Czech and Hungarian New Waves with more films achieving international acclaim and distribution ; the ‘silencing’ of the ‘Polish School’ 1963-71. The  sixties was a ‘golden age’ for Yugoslavia’s multinational film industry. Bulgarian cinema experienced its first period of growth to maturity, 1956-65, of a national ‘cinema of poetics’, “finding its audience via the image rather than than the word”.

1968-80. “Convergence and divergence” involving the co-existence and various ideological and aesthetic strategies in the art scene with intense artistic developments in major cities after 1968. Perspectives for new positions in international art and awareness of the avant garde with occasional situations of subversive dissident filmmaking. Continuous interest in historical topics, often as allegories. Mass production of mediocre and socially correct socialist dramas and comedies marking the split between art for international circulation and entertainment for domestic consumption. The beginning of the seventies heralded a breakthrough for “native thematic material” in the Bulgarian cinema, the state providing greater independence through the setting up of separate production units.            

*Adapted from a summary by Dina Iordanova                   

Jerzy Kawalerowicz b.22   Wojciech Has (1975) b.25   Andrzej Munk b.25   Tadeusz Konwicki b.26    Andrzej Wajda (1964) b.29    Roman Polanski (1967) b.33   Jerzy Skolimowski (1970) b.38                               

Figure in brackets indicates year selected as one of International Film Guide’s 5 Directors of the Year

The Polish School under stress

The second half of the sixties was marked by a widespread groundswell for social and political change in the western world. This came early in Poland in 1956 with the October uprising marking the retreat of Stalinism followed by four years of creative freedom that had not existed anywhere in Eastern Europe since 1945. “In the arts the principles of socialist realism were rejected, replaced by the aspiration for a “critical realism,” a renewal of questioning that had infused Polish ideological life through the 19th century” (Michalek & Turaj 28). Reforms introduced in July 1955 created self governing film-makers' production units with a degree of autonomy in decision-making. A modern Polish cinema was born with its own style, its own themes, its own spiritual and aesthetic identity known as “the Polish School' 1956-60. “Once put to retreat, socialist realism, “schematism,” disappeared quickly.” It had been in full operation in 1949 but did not have the staying power in Poland that it continued to have in Czechoslovakia and Hungary. “The mood in Poland supported a new liveliness in the arts,” 1955 being the milestone year (ibid 15).

Challenging films, including those with avant garde tendencies, were no longer proscribed. “A subjective approach diametrically opposed to socialist realism reigned supreme to an increasing degree. […] Polish directors approached reality more and more through the main character or characters, sometimes identifying directly with them.” (Liehm 181). Jan Rybkowski was inspired to advance a changed point of view in Godziny nadziei / The Hours of Hope (1955) in a story set in Germany when war is about to become peace creating “a climate of hope as well as one of disillusionment” (Michael & Turaj 15).

Andrzej Wajda

The “true auteurs” were 
Andrzej Wajda (1926-2016) and Andrzej Munk (1925-61). Wajda's work from A Generation(1954), his first feature, to Danton (1982) which he made in France, can be summed up as nearly three decades of fused irony and defiance installing him as a national figure in Poland who defied labelling as a realist, modernist or romantic in his on-going concern with the pitfalls and agonies of national identity (Orr 2-3).  Pokolenie/ A Generation (1955)as Nowell-Smith points out, is politically orthodox basically adhering to the proscriptions of socialist realism in ascribing the leading role in the resistance to the communists with the hero developing political consciousness as the story develops (New Wave 65). Both The Hours of Hope and A Generation  were nevertheless accused of imitating Italian neo-realism drawn into an on-going conflict in which neo-realism was accused of deep pessimism residing in naturalism’s tendency to dwell on the grimness of life while not foretelling victory of the proletariat in the class struggle (M&T 16)..

The second film in the trilogy is formally more adventurous in its romanticism most of the action taking place in the sewers under Warsaw with Wajda shedding some new light on the tragic national legend of the 1944 Warsaw uprising in Kanal / Canal (1957) showing how the participants were destroyed by conflicting forces. The writer Jerzy Stawinski's rationalism - he saw the absurdity of the military uprising played out before the waiting Soviet army - “dissolved into Wajda's romanticism and fateful tragedy” to take a more sympathetic view of the nationalist underground army than had previously been politically possible (Liehm 178; McArthur ).

While a complex neo-romanticism can be seen to arise from the Polish romantic tradition in Wajda's cinema, the aesthetics that departs from that legacy can arguably be found in the work of Munk, Has, Borowczyk and Skolimowski  (M.Goddard 144, Orr ed.).  Munk the ironist, in Zezowate Szeście/ Cock-eyed Luck (1960) is “often farcical and sometimes bitterly realistic in the mixture of various conventions from silent movies to socialist realism” (Michael & Turaj 124). On release it was popular with the public but critically controversial in the satire of political and social conformity, important for contributing to the national debate about history and patriotism with a view parallel to that of prominent writer Witold Gombriewicz attracting strong official criticism (ibid).   

Ashes and Diamonds

In the third film of Wadja’s trilogy, 
Popoli I diament/ Ashes and Diamonds (1958)based on Jerzy Andrzejewski's controversial novel written in 1948, it is evident that the Polish resistance was split into Communist and non-Communist (the Home Army) factions, capturing the hopelessness of so-called “moments of truth” through the prism of the war's official end.  Ashes and Diamonds is symptomatic of the films of this period in portraying the tragedy of postwar Poland still torn with internal dissension brought to light in all its ambiguity. Set on the first day of peace with Zbigniew Cybulski as Maciek the young resistance fighter in the anti-communist Home Army which had fought against both the Soviets and the Germans without official recognition.  Against Social Realist convention, Wajda and Cybulski extend to Maciek the ambiguous status of tragic anti-hero with a persona resembling Marlon Brando. He has to decide whether to carry out what is a pointless directive to murder an ageing Communist functionary, a veteran of the Spanish Civil War whose son, like his assassin, is a member of the nationalist army. The personal story of Pole facing Pole is set against the reality of postwar Poland, an expressionist vision blending with complex symbolism in Wajda's on-going sense, both romantic and ironic, after centuries of denial of Poland’s full nationhood.  

The cast of characters in the trilogy relate to each other in the ways in which a cross section of Polish society is presented. In Ashes and Diamonds, “communist and non-communist, aristocrat and worker, old bourgeois and new party bureaucrat” are shown dancing a sad polonaise at the end [of the film] while outside the old Communist is being murdered.”(McArthur)

Andrzej Munk

Munk was even more controversial with 
Eroica (1957), an ironic summing up of the national mythology. in the two separate stories comprising the film. “Reality is seen in Munk’s films through the eyes of his characters, imprisoned in certain unmistakable environments that symbolise their lack of freedom - the railway station in Man on the Track (1956), Warsaw of the uprising and the prison camp in Eroica , the mountain in The Blue Cross (1955), and the concentration camp in The Passenger” (Liehm 176).  

Munk died in a car accident after finishing the Auschwitz sequences of the The Passenger in September 1961. Colleagues decided to let the public see the assembled footage as it was made with an added narrative commentary leaving the meaning of the strange relationship between the two women - captor and victim in extreme circumstances - unresolved, subject only to Munk’s sternness in the creation of the background, the death camp, “a calculated coldness that by its very nature horrifies more than a portrayal in which the director’s sympathies are apparent.”  Munk creates “an ambivalent rather than a clear picture from the moral point of view [… ] the effect is not to excuse anything but to go deeper into what happened in this case between two people […] a search for motivations governing human behaviour” (M&T 127).

Eroica 

In 1958 Polish films gathered 15 awards at various international festivals. The next step was a change of theme to contemporary life.The end of the 50s in Poland, as well as Czechoslovakia and Hungary, saw a deterioration in relations between artists and government which by 1960 had gradually silenced  dissent. Wajda managed to complete, without making concessions, 
Niewinni czarnodzieje/ The Innocent Sorcerers (1960) a film about young people co-scripted with Lodz film school graduate, Jerzy Skolimowski.  The finished work was severely criticised by the authorities. The period of freedom from the strictures of socialist realism had been short lived. In what was referred to as a ‘small stabilisation’ the Politburo closed down the ‘Polish School’ in 1960 after it was attacked by Party authorities. This introduced a decade of harsh administration along ideological lines resulting in the relative stagnation of Polish film production through the 60s.

Polish poster for Everything for Sale

Following the success of the war trilogy plus 
Lotna (1959) both in Poland and in establishing his international reputation, Wajda averaged almost one feature a year through the sixties despite their varying success with the public and critics while being subject to more or less ongoing political flak from  the bureaucracy. His one fully engaged work at this time was the reflexive Wsystko na sprzedaz/ Everything for Sale (1967) described as “adhering to the New Wave model of authorship” from his own screenplay following the void left by the untimely accidental death of Zbigniew Cybulski - he was to have played the main role. Wadja redirected the film to be about the fact of the young actor's death. “There was nothing about the Polish cause […] it is quite different from anything he'd done before […] It does link with the theme of generations which he and Cybulski had explored together before.” Originally it was intended that Skolimowski would play the role of the director in which Andrezj Łapicki was finally  cast.  The filmmaker in the film has no doubts concerning one issue: cinema has to be reinvented” (Lubelski  ed.Orr 33). Stylistically it was a new departure. Scenes that dramatise the production of the film overlap with actual scenes of the film being produced, interspersed with documentary footage (Cybulski's funeral) and real comments and observations made by Cybulski's friends and some fans. In comparison with Wajda’s previous work, Everything for Sale could be seen as “a kind of ragged conversation about death and other things seen retrospectively, a rumination about past and present and what fact and fiction have in common, and also a record, an inclusive filmmaking experiment “that is also a remarkable achievement” (Michatek & Turaj 144).

The end put to the Polish School by the Gomulka government meant the 60s was a bleak decade of “silence” especially for Polish art cinema. As noted, Wajda continued to make films it would seem, too often without conviction, as 'experiments'. In mid-decade he involved himself again with the encounter between humanity and history. In Popioly/ Ashes (1965) his inspiration was a neo-romantic novel by Stefan Zeromski, centred historically on the Poles allying themselves with Napoleon in the hope of regaining their statehood from Russia, Prussia and Austria. This allowed Wajda to embrace “as the stable character of his films: the freedom fighter who is left disillusioned and sceptical by his struggle, but seems to retain his nobility” (Liehm 369). A tragic role is played by Polish patriots “fighting for their own freedom only to end up suppressing the freedom of others.”  The size and scope of the production was huge and attracted much attention including some of the  finest sequences Wajda ever filmed , such as the capture of Saragossa. But the philosophy attracted “profound disapproval,” Wajda finding himself again under attack (ibid).

Landscape After Battle

Wajda's “finest film of the decade,”  
Krajobraz po bitwie/ Landscape after Battle (1970), marked his return to high seriousness, the great Polish problems and the atmosphere of despair. Based on the novel of “an extraordinary writer,” Tadeusz Borowski, who survived a boyhood in Auschwitz, 'The Battle of Grumwald’, is set in an American displaced person’s camp in Germany in 1945. The main theme is  still “the Polish character” but in line with the novel the film is “complex and ambiguous in its presentation of the hero and the other inmates of the camp” (Micatek & Turaj 146).

Wojciech Has

Wojciech Has
 (1925-2000) was most prolific in the 60s. He was an individualist not associated with any group or movement (Michael  & Turaj 39). His fifth feature Juk być kochanq/ How to be Loved (1963), a psychological drama divided into two sections is about an actress on a flight from Paris after the war recalling life under Nazi Occupation - the suffering, love, disappointment, and disaster. Carefully directed by Has is “a consummate performance by Barbara Kraft.” What emerges through personal pieces of biography is “an historical picture comparable to that of the Polish School.” (ibid). In his second feature Pozegnania/ Farewells (1958), “had concentrated on the atmosphere of uncertainty and despair in Poland in 1939 when people, traditions, objects, memories, and relationships were doomed. An obtrusive tone of nostalgia for something that perhaps never existed imbues Farewells with an unusual sensuous fascination” (Liehm 183). Has made his break from more intimate drama into grand historical mode with an extraordinary original period piece, a surrealist drama, the Buñuelian Recopis znaieziony w Saragossie/ The Saragossa Manuscript (1964), “was a super production in every way […] the story takes place nowhere except in the tale” (M&T 39), a collection of fantastical tales dating back to 1815, inspired by the Decameron and Arabian Nights based on what is apparently an equally extraordinary 19th century Polish novel written in French by a Polish aristocrat Jan Potocki who viewed literature as an intellectual game. “Clearly Has was not going to be involved with the main themes of Polish cinema...He chose a separate and private route for his expression” (ibid 33).

Jerzy Kawalerowicz directing Pharoah

The last significant films of the Polish School were made by 
Jerzy Kawalerowicz (1922-2007) who rarely touched the great problems of Poland’s national existence; “he dealt with universal and diversified themes, while going through a number of stylistic metamorphoses” (ibid 94). In his fifth feature Pociag/ Night Train (1959) Kawalerowicz shows how formal mastery in staging a one night train journey through mise-en-scène, can atmospherically transform the spatial restrictions of a seemingly conventional melodrama into a different reality, suspicion transforming peaceful passengers into a hateful mob who then return to the smothering normality on a journey whose goals are unclear. “No other film has been so adept at creating the impression of nihilism. This film journey brings no resolution...except the diffusion of self and the coming of emptiness” (Frank Guido, 'Cinema nuouo' 1960). Kovács describes Night Train “as a spectacular break with the dilemma between romantic heroism and everyday realism” the former continuing to dominate the wartime genre films as in Wajda’s Lotna released in the same year. When it opened, Night Train was dismissed as banal, empty, and pretentious by most Polish critics, “still under the spell of what they saw as great national themes”. Elsewhere in Europe it was more widely recognised as “something quite new in its subtle themes and form, something masterful” (Michatek & Turaj 102). Kovács concludes: that Polish cinema took its part in the general European emergence of modernism in 1959, was due to one director and his film Night Train (286).

The other film in which his thematic eclecticism and formal mastery is most evident, one of Kawalerowicz's last and best films on the theme of intolerance and dogmatism and the conflict between faith and love, Marka Joanna od Aniolów/ Mother Joan of the Angels (1961), is adapted from a novel by contemporary writer Jaroslaw Iwaszkiewicz sourced in the witchcraft trials at the Loudon Convent in France in the 17th Century. The witchcraft trials are also subject of a book by Aldous Huxley and numerous other works including Ken Russell's film The Devils (1971). The central relationship is between Mother Joan the possessed nun, and the exorcist Father Suryn. The initial coldness between them grows into something more sinful leading to the murder of two servants by the priest. This raises various questions including a possible exchange of souls to which there is no clear answer. The accompanying psychological tension and pain is palpably visualised by Kawalerowicz, his cameraman and art director, through the use of geometrical lines, black and white contrast, and horizontally tracking camera. Deepening allegory that destroys both inquisitors and victims, is further reinforced by the sound of the strangely echoing voices of singing nuns. Kawalerowicz felt that the subject imposed the visual form.

In his next film Faraon/ Pharaoh (1966), set in ancient Egypt (shot in Kazakhstan, the Valley of the Kings in Egypt and the Lodz studio), based on a classic Polish novel written by Boleslaw Prus adapted by Konwicki (q.v.), was part of the trend towards super productions in a time of political restriction on contemporary subjects - it was made in the same year as Wajda's Ashes. In place of the spectacle of large events and set pieces (there is only one obligatory battle) with slow and majestic ballet-like narration “the characters using hieratic and ritual gestures conventionalized like the celebration of a mass” (M &T 106). The central concerns are with psychological, moral and philosophical problems wholly fictionalised in the novel. The young ruler, Rameses XIII, in the 9th century BC is fictional. His nobility of purpose is in strategic conflict with the experienced political cunning of the priests. The subject of the novel and the film is “the mechanism of power and the morality of politics” (ibid). Kawalerowicz’s films seemed to evolve one from another as M&T note (110) as in the theme of political power and morality from Pharaoh to a “remarkable historical docudrama,” Death of a President (1976), the director’s only immersion in Polish history, “without diminishing the elements of tension, suspense and story.”

Tadeusz Konwicki

Tadeusz Konwicki
 (1926-2015) one of Poland's outstanding writers to have emerged since the war, turned to screenwriting in his original style - intelligent, witty and sceptical – attracting public attention. He co-directed Ostatni dzeri lata/ Last Day of Summer (1958) with Jan Laskowski on a miniscule budget with no crew, a cameraman and two actors in the period of freedom from socialist realism. Beneath the surface subject is a secondary theme which became central to Konwicki's later work: the emotional destruction wrought by the war on people described as being “contaminated by death.”

This underlying theme was further developed in Konwicki’s first full-scale feature Zaduszki/ All Soul's Day (1961) closer to the subjective approach, assuming tragic irony in Salto (1965) bringing to mind much of the tradition of Polish literature in the story of a man wearing dark glasses (Zbigniew Cybulski) who arrives in a small town where he surrounds himself in ambiguity with a different story for everyone, pretending he used to live there during the German occupation. The town is full of characters each claiming connection with him in some way, initially accepting him as a prophet. He succeeds in involving  all in mystifying problems, comic and tragic, climaxing in teaching them a traditional dance called the salto - “full of symbols and relics of the Polish school” - in “a long metaphoric sequence” before he is rejected. “Polish critics welcomed Salto with enthusiasm as the first systematic demystification of the Polish character and the Polish wartime legend, even though the tragic undertone that resounds in Salto seems to indicate rather the opposite  (Liehm 372).  

Roman Polanski

Roman Polanski'
s only Polish feature was Nóź w wodzie/ Knife in the Water (1962). Within the bounds of a realistic style, a power struggle with abstract connotations develops involving three people on a small yacht. The power struggle that develops assumes a more general social theme in the psychological duel between the self confident, dominant older man and the much younger hitchhiking stranger, the woman resilient in the face of male domination. The image of the younger generation projected in the film initially concerned the censors. The film attracted extraordinary attention in both Western Europe and the US, providing the impetus for Polanski to seek a film career outside Poland.

Jerzy Skolimowski

Polanski's collaborator on the script of 
Knife in the Water was Jerzy Skolimowski who wrote and directed a stylistically radical semi-autobiographical trilogy, 1964-66, ‘the Leszcyc cycle’ in which he also plays the central character Andrezj Leszcyc in the first two: the last day as a student before army service in Rysopis:Identification Marks None, a boxer who has lost the will to win in Walkover, and a stand-in for himself as a radically non-conformist student in Bariera/ Barrier*. The poetically layered narrative unfolds with a “freewheeling improvisatory individualism” which Skolimowski described as “the mental landscape” expressive of Andrzej's distance from the cynical conformity of his generation's ambition. In this, Skolimowski was close to Konwicki (see above). Leszcyc returns in the similarly surreal-inflected Rece do góry!/ Hands Up!(1967), gathering with friends to celebrate their material success at the tenth anniversary of their graduation from tertiary college. The present gathering engages in an imagined reenactment in a cattle car of a kind of schematic nightmarish stage play representing a traumatic experience where real time is suspended (Iordanova 76).  Flashbacks constitute Skolimowski's sharpest satire of Stalinist intolerance overlain by ironies in the present of “a society enclosed in a vicious circle” symbolised by the gesture of ‘hands up’, resulting in the film’s banning from public exhibition in Poland. Skolimowski in the words of the Liehms, “profoundly marked by the experience of Stalinism and by his own hatred of dogma,” chose to go into semi-permanent exile in 1968, one of the worst years for the Polish film industry outperformed by most European countries, locked in a ‘silence’ of politically imposed conformity.

Skolimowski’s quartet, Nowell-Smith describes as “a one-man bridge between the Polish School that seemingly fell apart in the early 1960s and the emergence of the ‘cinema of moral concern’ inaugurated by Krzysztof Zanussi, another Lodz graduate, whose first film, The Structure of Crystals, was released in 1969” ( ‘Making Waves’ 168).                                                                                                                          

* Surrealistically signified by the face of the actor playing Leszcyc wrapped in a poster of Skolimowski’s face when riding a chute on a case.

********************************

Marek Hendrykowski, “East Central Europe” Oxford History of World Cinema 1996 Nowell-Smith ed.  

Dina Iordanova Cinema of the Other Europe  2003 

John Orr & Elzbieta Ostrowska eds. The Cinema of Andrej Wajda 2003 

Boleslaw Michalek & Frank Turaj  The Modern Cinema of Poland  1988   

Ewa Mazierska  Jerzy Skoklmowski The Cinema of a Nonconformist   2010 

Bruce Hodsdon “Great Directors: Jerzy Skolimowski Senses of Cinema July 2003    

Colin McArthur “Andrzej Wajda: Films from the Ashes”  Movies of the Fifties  ed. Ann Lloyd 1982

David Sterritt   “Early Jerzy Skolimowski” Cineaste Fall 2024

*******************************

Previous entries in this series can be found if you click the following links

 

Sixty Years of International Art Cinema: 1960-2020 - Tables and Directors Lists to Accompany Bruce Hodsdon's Series

 

Notes on canons, methods, national cinemas and more

 

Part One - Introduction

Part Two - Defining Art Cinema

Part Three - From Classicism to Modernism

Part Four - Authorship and Narrative

Part Five - International Film Guide Directors of the Year, The Sight and Sound World Poll, Art-Horror

Part Six (1) - The Sixties, the United States and Orson Welles

Part Six (2) - Hitchcock, Romero and Art Horror

Part Six (3) - New York Film-makers - Elia Kazan & Shirley Clarke  

Part Six (4) - New York Film-makers - Stanley Kubrick Creator of Forms

Part Six (5) ‘New Hollywood’ (1) - Arthur Penn, Warren Beatty, Pauline Kael and BONNIE AND CLYDE

Part Six (6) Francis Ford Coppola: Standing at the crossroads of art and industry

Part 6(7) Altman

6(8) Great Britain - Joseph Losey, Lindsay Anderson, Karel Reisz, Richard Lester, Peter Watkins, Barney Platts-Mills

6(9) France - Part One The New Wave and The Cahiers du Cinema Group

6(10) France - Part Two - The Left Bank/Rive Gauche Group and an Independent

6(11) France - Part Three - Young Godard

6(12) France - Part Four - Godard:Visionary and Rebel

6 (13) France Part 5 Godard with Gorin, Miéville : Searching for an activist voice

6(14) France Part 6 - Creator of Forms - Bresson 

6 (15) France Part 6 - Creator of Forms - Jacques Tati

 6 (16) - Part 6 - Creator of Forms - Carl Th Dreyer

6 (17) - Italy and Luchino Visconti

6(18 - Italy and Roberto Rossellini - Part One

6(19) - Rossellini, INDIA and the new Historical realism

6(20) - Rossellini in Australia

6 (21) - Italy - Michelangelo Antonioni

6 (22) - Italy - Federico Fellini, Ermanno Olmi

6 (23) - Italy - Pasolini, Rosi

6 (24) - Interregnum - Director/Auteur/Autoren

6 (25) West Germany

6 (26) - Alexander Kluge Part One

6 (27) - Alexander Kluge Part Two

6 (28) - The Young German Cinema: Reitz, Schlondorff, von Trotta

6(29 ) West German Cinema - Fassbinder

6 (30) West German Cinema - Straub & Huillet

6(31) - New Spanish Cinema

6 (32) - Bunuel in the 60s

6 (33) Nordic Cinemas - Bergman and Widerberg

6 (34) - Scandinavia - Sjoman, Zetterling, Troell

6 (35) - East Germany - Konrad Wolf, Frank Beyer

CINEMA REBORN - DECEMBER NEWSLETTER - First Program Hints, Admission Prices, A Tribute to Tom Zubrycki, Charitable Donations

 

FIRST PROGRAM HINTS

Cinema Reborn’s full program for 2025 will be announced in mid-March and our supporters will be able to book for the entire seasons in Sydney at the Ritz Cinemas Randwick and in Melbourne at the Lido Cinemas Hawthorn from that date. Our website will have short notes and links to bookings and you will be able to pick up a copy of our leaflet at each cinema.


In the meantime, we can give our first program hint of what’s to come. Starting early in 2025, Ritz Cinemas Randwick and Lido Cinemas Hawthorn will be presenting the first complete retrospective in Australia of one of the major figures in 20th century cinema. The season will conclude when the director’s final film is presented as part of Cinema Reborn’s 2025 season. We can’t share the details yet, but we can say that when it was released, the director’s final film won the Grand Prix at Cannes and the BAFTA for Best Foreign Language Film.

 

All up in 2025 Cinema Reborn will present 20 programmes including  an expanded program devoted to newly-restored Australian films.


CINEMA REBORN ADMISSION PRICES

Admission  prices  for all sessions at Cinema Reborn are at regular prices and significant discounts are available to those who are members of the Ritz and Lido Movie Clubs. Go to the cinemas’ websites and click on “Membership” to get the details.


A TRIBUTE TO TOM ZUBRYCKI

Tom Zubrycki  is one of Australia's leading documentary film-makers. For over forty years  he has chronicled Australian society. His awards include the Stanley Hawes Award in recognition of an outstanding contribution to Australian Documentary, the Cecil Holmes Award from the Australian Directors Guild, and an International Emmy.


Cinema Reborn, OZDOX and the Randwick Ritz are proud to present  a screening of newly restored copies of two of Tom’s highly regarded landmark films: KEMIRA – DIARY OF A STRIKE (1984) and HOMELANDS (1993). Tom will introduce the films and take part in a conversation about his life, career and documentary film-making in Australia. The evening will be hosted by Maree Delofski - filmmaker, scholar and historian.

5.00 PM ON SUNDAY 8 DECEMBER
BOOKINGS IF YOU CLICK HERE 


CHARITABLE DONATIONS

Once again Cinema Reborn has established a page to enable our supporters to make tax-deductible donations to support our work. Our organisation is run by a group of film industry professionals, working critics, curators and film conservation specialists. All work in an entirely voluntary capacity. Nevertheless there are significant costs, most notably our screening fees, which have to be met each year and we are always grateful for the financial support we receive that defrays these costs and charges. If you would like to make a donation you may do so via via the attached link established by the Australian Cultural Fund which enables small unincorporated organisations like ours to use a service which would otherwise not be easily accessible. To make a donation any time between now and the end of Cinema Reborn 2025 click on this link 


DATES FOR 2025

Cinema Reborn 2025 will be presented at the Randwick Ritz from 30 April to 6 May and at the Hawthorn Lido from 8 to 13 May.


EMAIL LIST

To join Cinema Reborn's email list for a mostly monthly email send your address to cinemareborn2025@gmail.com

Sunday, 24 November 2024

Sixty Years of International Art Cinema - Bruce Hodsdon continues his series - 6 (35) Eastern Europe - East Germany - Konrad Wolf, Frank Beyer


The DEFA generation

The postwar formation of the sole production company in the East, the state-controlled DEFA, was officially founded as a Soviet company in1946.  It was set-up at the ex-UFA studio at Potsdam-Babelsberg with a traditional studio structure modelled on pre-war UFA and Hollywood. The immediate postwar years saw the production of several enduring classics most notably Wolfgang Staudte's anti-Nazi thriller Dit Mörder sind unter uns / The Murderers are Among Us (1946) filmed prior to the setting  up of the DEFA studio, made with the permission of the Soviet occupiers after the Americans and French had refused permission. Stylistically Staudte re-employs expressionist lighting in the tradition of pre-Nazi UFA . It was released in the GDR in 1955 and the Federal Republic in 1971.

A major DEFA success at this time was Ehe I’m Schatten / Marriage in the Shadows (1947) directed by Kurt Maetzig, his first feature tells the story of a couple, actors being driven to suicide by the Nazis because she is Jewish. It was shown to an audience of more than 10 million across the then all four military sectors of Germany.  Erich Engel directed Affaire Blum (1948) based on an actual crime committed in the early 1930s when the state authorities covered up a murder by blaming it on an innocent Jew.  Staudte’s Der Untertan / The Kaiser’s Lackey (1951) for years banned from screening in West Germany, is adapted from a novel by Heinrich Mann, a biting satire on the German petit bourgeoisie. The promise of these postwar years at DEFA “under rather liberal Soviet supervision” ended around 1950 when the Soviet film officials handed DEFA over to German Stalinists after the foundation of the GDR. Film production reached a low point in 1952. A Communist Party conference proclaimed a new doctrine to intensify the methods of ‘socialist realism’ using ‘positive socialist heroes’  and dealing more with the problems of the working class movement.  Few such films were actually produced DEFA preferring to follow a policy of presenting the GDR as the inheritor of the German cultural tradition by adapting classic dramas and famous fairytales and also entering into a series of co-productions mainly with France  (Bock 628).

Konrad Wolf

The Soviet Thaw of 1956 following Krushchev’s denunciation of Stalinism, encouraged an emerging  generation of German directors to find new ways of dealing with contemporary and anti-Fascist topics. Bock identifies the most important of this postwar DEFA generation as 
Konrad Wolf (1925-82) whose Jewish father, a doctor and well-known author, Friedrich Wolf, was an outspoken Communist Party member in Germany from 1928. Konrad left for Moscow with the family in 1934 to live in exile where, as a naturalised Soviet citizen he served in the Red Army during the war and began studying film in Moscow in 1949.  He started directing at DEFA in the 50s. Following the Soviet crackdowns in Hungary and Poland in 1956 Wolf was one of the critics of Ulbricht’s regime in East Germany, maintaining faith for more democratic developments (Liehm 260). That he managed to hold his position seems based on the intent of the authorities not to incur further loss of creative talent in the postwar years.

Wolf’s first popular success was Lissy (1957) based on a novel written in the 30s by F.C. Weiskopf, the portrait of a working class girl set in one of three main categories of subject put to the severe test of political correctness: a film set in the 30s and the rise of Nazism. Wolf’s screen adaptation remains close to the novel in conveying a psychologically convincing portrait of fascism’s appeal to the petty bourgeoisie in the careful treatment of milieu and atmosphere. His deployment of montage has its origins in his early training in the Soviet Union coupled with a documentary quality in compositions arising from his familiarity with Italian Neo-Realism (Silberman).

Lissy

In place of genres there were categories of subject based on the past: films about the 30s and the rise of fascism; films about the war and immediate postwar years; films about contemporary GDR society. 
DEFA also balanced heavy-handed ideological content by filming more suspense dramas and comedies.

Wolf’s fourth film, Sonnensucher/  Sun-seeker (1958), filmed during the post-Stalinist thaw, is a bleak portrayal of the lives of German and Russian uranium miners in the late 40s in a neo-realist inspired style. It was withdrawn just prior to its premiere and was not officially released until 1972.  The reason for its banning had nothing to do with the style or content of the film but, typical of the GDR’s political subservience, at the time of the film’s opening the Soviet Union called for the banning of nuclear weapons (259).  

Sterne/Stars (1959), co-directed by Wolf with Rangel Vulchanov, is the story of a Nazi officer who falls in love with a Greek Jewish girl while escorting prisoners to a prison camp in Bulgaria. It was “exceptional for its poetic depiction of a small Bulgarian town in wartime […] For the first time in an East German film, feelings take precedence over the prejudices of the time.” (Liehm 263).  Stars won a Special Jury prize at Cannes and was widely distributed internationally.          


“A paradigmatic DEFA treatment” of Jews by the Nazis, the remake of a 1938 Soviet film, 
Professor Mamlock (1961), based on a play written by Wolf's father while in exile in France in 1933, the story of an apolitical professor who takes up the anti-Nazi cause too late. In the Liehm's view Mamlock is well below Wolf's best work, to which he seemed to concur, although it was a modest box office success. When asked why he remade the film Wolf said he thought the central focus was not the persecution of the Jews but the destiny of a liberal intellectual forsaken by his class.

Der geteilte Himmel/Divided Sky (1964) from a ‘new novel’ by Christa Wolf (not related to the director) was rewritten for the screen by Konrad Wolf working with the author in the culmination of his earlier efforts to find a new narrative form in telling the novel’s story of lovers separated by the border of the two Germanys. Using flashbacks interwoven with images of the present, Wolf put together fragments of the heroine’s conversations, memories, and introspections in which the psychology of a divided country the fundamental theme in the book, “yields primacy on the screen to social argumentation” (Liehm 267). Wolf’s treatment aroused controversy about the acceptability of formalism versus a more conservative classical style of storytelling.

Frank Beyer

Bock notes that “some of the most interesting stylistic approaches were to be found in films that dealt with the Fascist past, a field that was politically correct” (629). 
Frank Beyer (1932-2006), a graduate of the Prague Film Academy, took “a more human approach” to his fictional filmmaking by concentrating on sentimental aspects of stories in which human destinies were melodramatically presented while political aspects were at times even relinquished altogether from the script as in Beyer’s debut Zwei Mutter/Two Mothers (1957).  He followed this theatrical style with a Spanish Civil War story, Five Cartridge Cases (1960), tracing the theme through the lives of five people. He used expressionistic techniques to evoke the atmosphere of pre-and post war Germany in Koningskinder / Invincible Love (1961). The influence of the new Polish and Czech cinemas was evident in Beyer’s Konigskinder /Royal Children (1962)He then made several anti-fascist films, the stylistically experimental Star Crossed Loves (1962) and Naked Among Wolves (1963), a classic anti-Nazi DEFA drama set in Buchenwald concentration camp, a story of prisoners risking their lives to hide a Jewish boy.  

The closing of the East-West border in August 1961 marked by the construction of the Berlin Wall, resulted in a short-lived hope amongst artists and intellectuals in the GDR - especially those favourable to socialist ideals - for more freedom to criticise internal social and economic problems (ibid). Frank Beyer hinted at economic difficulties in a comedy Karbid und sauerampfer/ Carbide and Sorrel (1963). Other directors were working on new critical films in November 1965  when the crackdown came initiated by Party Secretary Walter Ulbricht’s letter to Kurt Maetzig criticising his film,The Rabbit is Me (1965), and calling for opposition to deviations from the party’s ideological orthodoxy. The attack was concentrated against voices calling for a more liberal cultural policy. A number of new films were criticised by the Plenary Session of the Central Committee that ostensibly “sullied the first German state of workers and farmers.” As the Liehms put it, “none of [the ‘rabbit’ films] found their way into movie theatres, and all that was left of the DEFA’s 1965-66 season was a pile of rubble.”

The Rabbit is Me

Almost the whole of DEFA’s production team was accused and indicted for ‘scepticism’ and ‘subjectivism’. The top executives at DEFA were removed and some directors careers were destroyed. Konrad Wolf resisted, formulating notes for discussion raising the question : “What now?…If all our films dealing with contemporary topics are wrong- then something must be wrong with the ideology - clear logic!” DEFA retreated into making Indianerfilme’ (‘Red Indian films’) “showing how native Indians were suppressed by greedy white Americans - some even containing allusions to the Vietnam war” (Bock 630).

Beyer was obliged to take up a new career in tv production and theatre after Spur fer Steine/ Track of Stones (1966)  because he failed to conform to the myths surrounding the “heroes of socialist labor.’’ Even though Beyer played down the hypocritical character of a careerist Party secretary as it was portrayed in the best selling novel, after a successful opening the film was withdrawn “for distorting the image of our socialist reality” (Liehm 361). He returned to feature filmmaking in 1975 with his greatest critical and popular success, Jakob der Lugner / Jakob the Liar. “Because of its subject (a poetic tale of life in a Jewish ghetto during the Nazi era) the film was turned down by the Moscow Film Festival but became East German entry in the Berlin Festival, the first ever to compete in the West (Liehm 361).

 

Jacob the Liar

An autobiographical testimony 
Ich war neunzehn / I was Nineteen (1968), based on Wolf's wartime experiences as a German-born Soviet soldier in Germany during the last days of the war invites the construction of questions and answers on identity; Nineteen and Stars, established Wolf's international reputation. All his films in this decade plus Mama Ich lebe / Mama I'm Alive (1976) deal either with the Nazi past or the formative years of the GDR, made with Wolf's ability to dramatise great historical moments with social and political changes focused through individual subjectivity  (Leonhard 61).

All the leading DEFA directors, including Wolf, ran into problems with contemporary subjects. They reacted by turning to the 'safe' topics of anti-fascism or disguising politically controversial contemporary themes by employing literary classics or the biographies of artists as a means of exploring the conflict between the individual and society. Wolf directed the historical epic Goya or the Hard Way to Enlightenment (1971) in fulfilment of a long standing  intention on his part to film a parable of the artist’s destiny in society. Goya is adapted from a novel which focuses on the Spanish artist's personality as he asserts himself against opposing social forces – monarchy, church, revolution. It was given maximum funding in a co-production with the Soviet Union employing  actors and technicians from eight countries to achieve 'artistic quality’.The tendency towards a Hollywood epic for international and box office success was far removed, aesthetically speaking, from Wolf's small scale films in historical settings. Silberman comments that Wolf took the opportunity in Goya to also “explore the historical and psychological limits of an artist in exile echoing the novelist Feuchwinger's own experience in political exile and Wolf's own practical knowledge of the effect of constraints on the imagination in the GDR.”

Wolf continued the theme of the artist in society with a Kohlhaase screenplay but in a very different mode in Der nackte Mann auf dem Sportsplatz / The Naked Man in the Sports Ground (1973), based on the life of one of East Germany's most important sculptors Werner Stötzer in an episodic satirical tragi-comedy free of stereotypes in alluding to the Nazi persecution on the Jews alongside the often unsuccessful daily struggle of the artist. The aesthetic differences between these two films and and also between them and Solo Sunny (1979) are striking. The latter is about the problem-driven life of a nightclub singer, focusing on the individual and what art means to her. Rather than serving society, she struggles for a balance between professional and personal needs, her art offering the possibility of self-realisation.

Solo Sunny

Silberman concludes that Wolf's sensitivity to the past in much of his previous work adapted to the needs of East Germany in the present, is further shaped by his collaboration with talented writer Wolfgang Kohlhaase beginning with 
I was Nineteen. Kohlhaase had already established a reputation for successful scenarios about the problems of youthThey controversially decided, if only superficially, to return to what Silberman refers to as the 'action mode' of Lissy, Wolf's first popular success.  For Solo Sunny (1979) they chose a contemporary protagonist but with a dramatic but open-ended plot and characterisation involving the rhythms of performance, her unhappy love affair and attempted suicide. This “barely conceals the intrinsically episodic character of the dramaturgy developed by Wolf over the preceding twenty years.”  On its release the Party immediately reacted, not by imposing censorship but by demanding in the official press a more positive view of 'socialist society'. This alarmed and convinced Wolf, in his words, “of the need for debate on immediate, real, everyday life in the present which is full of conflicts and questions.” Solo Sunny, a success with audiences in both East and West Germany, seemed to signify a turning point in Wolf's career in a more relaxed political environment only to be cut short by his premature death.

********************************************************

Marc Silberman “Remembering History: The Filmmaker Konrad Wolf” New German Critique 49  Winter 1990           

Sigrun D. Leonhard in Post New Wave Cinema in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union ed. D Goulding 1989 

Mira & Antonin J Liehm The Most Important Art East European Film After 1945  1977 pp.259-71, 359-68                       

Hans-Michael Bock   “The DEFA Story” The Oxford History of World Cinema  ed. Geoffrey Nowell-Smith 1996  

*****************************************************************       

Previous entries in this series can be found if you click the following links

 

Sixty Years of International Art Cinema: 1960-2020 - Tables and Directors Lists to Accompany Bruce Hodsdon's Series

 

Notes on canons, methods, national cinemas and more

 

Part One - Introduction

Part Two - Defining Art Cinema

Part Three - From Classicism to Modernism

Part Four - Authorship and Narrative

Part Five - International Film Guide Directors of the Year, The Sight and Sound World Poll, Art-Horror

Part Six (1) - The Sixties, the United States and Orson Welles

Part Six (2) - Hitchcock, Romero and Art Horror

Part Six (3) - New York Film-makers - Elia Kazan & Shirley Clarke  

Part Six (4) - New York Film-makers - Stanley Kubrick Creator of Forms

Part Six (5) ‘New Hollywood’ (1) - Arthur Penn, Warren Beatty, Pauline Kael and BONNIE AND CLYDE

Part Six (6) Francis Ford Coppola: Standing at the crossroads of art and industry

Part 6(7) Altman

6(8) Great Britain - Joseph Losey, Lindsay Anderson, Karel Reisz, Richard Lester, Peter Watkins, Barney Platts-Mills

6(9) France - Part One The New Wave and The Cahiers du Cinema Group

6(10) France - Part Two - The Left Bank/Rive Gauche Group and an Independent

6(11) France - Part Three - Young Godard

6(12) France - Part Four - Godard:Visionary and Rebel

6 (13) France Part 5 Godard with Gorin, Miéville : Searching for an activist voice

6(14) France Part 6 - Creator of Forms - Bresson 

6 (15) France Part 6 - Creator of Forms - Jacques Tati

 6 (16) - Part 6 - Creator of Forms - Carl Th Dreyer

6 (17) - Italy and Luchino Visconti

6(18 - Italy and Roberto Rossellini - Part One

6(19) - Rossellini, INDIA and the new Historical realism

6(20) - Rossellini in Australia

6 (21) - Italy - Michelangelo Antonioni

6 (22) - Italy - Federico Fellini, Ermanno Olmi

6 (23) - Italy - Pasolini, Rosi

6 (24) - Interregnum - Director/Auteur/Autoren

6 (25) West Germany

6 (26) - Alexander Kluge Part One

6 (27) - Alexander Kluge Part Two

6 (28) - The Young German Cinema: Reitz, Schlondorff, von Trotta

6(29 ) West German Cinema - Fassbinder

6 (30) West German Cinema - Straub & Huillet

6(31) - New Spanish Cinema

6 (32) - Bunuel in the 60s

6 (33) Nordic Cinemas - Bergman and Widerberg

6 (34) - Scandinavia - Sjoman, Zetterling, Troell